Teen Accuses Record Companies Of Collusion
Story by: Tom Duffy
Robert Santangelo, a 16-year-old being sued by five record companies accusing him of online music piracy, shot back Tuesday by accusing the recording industry of violating antitrust laws, conspiring to defraud the courts and making extortionate threats.
Santangelo, who was 11 when the alleged piracy occurred, denied ever illegally downloading music and said it’s impossible to prove that he did. Santangelo is the son of Patti Santangelo, the 42-year-old mother of five who was sued by the record companies in 2005. She refused to settle, took her case public and became a hero to supporters of Internet freedom. The record companies dropped their case against her in December, but still sued Robert and his sister Michelle, now 20, in federal court.
Michelle has been ordered to pay $30,750 in a default judgment because she did not respond to the lawsuit. Robert’s defense includes claims that he never sent copyrighted music to others, that the recording companies promoted file sharing before turning against it, that average computer users were never warned that it was illegal, that the statute of limitations has passed and that all the music claimed to have been downloaded was actually owned by his sister on store-bought CDs.
The Recording Industry Association Of America issued a statement saying, “The record industry has suffered enormously due to piracy. That includes thousands of layoffs. We must protect our rights. Nothing in a filing full of recycled charges that have gone nowhere in the past changes that fact.”
I love reading stories like this because instead of the RIAA saying “oh, we messed up. Our bad” what they’ll do is try to weasel their way out of making it seem like they’re doing anything wrong.
I’ll be honest, I do download music, but on the same token I also buy a lot of music as well. A lot of the music on my hard drive is stuff that I owned previously or music that I downloaded with the intent of buying. Some of it is rare and out of print and since my checkbook has my last name on it, I can’t be spending the thousands of dollars that it would take to purchase. Hell, I have a hard enough time paying rent on time.
I’m sure it has been said over and over, but if the major labels really wanted to boost sales, maybe they’d sign an artist that has some sort of talent instead of pawning off the next Fergie or whoever has the biggest tits this week on the world.
And I’ve been hooked on Brian Posehn’s album, Live In: Nerd Rage this week. The following video has modern metal down to cinch. Support this young and good looking feller.